Pike River Mining Tragedy

pike river mine

A lack of Safety Governance and an escalation of accumulated issues went tragically wrong on this New Zealand Coal Mine

Just recently I was completing a case study on the Pike River Mining Tragedy and its relevance to safety in general and governance in particular. The tragedy took place on 19th November 2010 in New Zealand’s South Island and resulted in the death of 29 miners with only two survivors; one of those killed was only 17 years old and on his first day on the job (he started a day early).

The exact ignition source of the methane explosion is not known but the failings of management prior to the explosion are now well documented and in the public domain thanks to the Royal Commission of Enquiry led by Justice Graham Panckhurst and the two volumes of report running to hundreds of pages.

The failings began with the directors and senior managers of the company who failed to exercise safety governance of the developing mine and abdicated their safety responsibilities to people much further down the line and, further, failed either to seek advice, or to heed the advice of the subject experts who were called in prior to the disaster.

Other failings included lack of adequate safety support, no appointed Ventilation Manager, Lack of Competence amongst workers, lack of planning, differing standards for employees and contractors, evidence of tampering with safety devices, poorly planned and executed ventilation, use of contraband underground, poor government regulations… the list just goes on and on.

What is most striking for me though was the rush to get production coal out of the mine… Mine development had been held up because of difficult rock conditions in reaching the coal mining areas and the location of the mine in a conservation area: Due to this management were really in a hurry to begin profitable work and this, together with a myriad of other acts and omissions lead to the tragedy.

This space is far too small to go into a lot of detail on this tragedy, but one detail is clear, if you shirk your responsibilities on Safety Governance the road from there-on is slippery one and nothing good can come of it… If you are in a senior position you need to know your Safety Governance Roles and enforce them diligently.

See my blog on MTR Safety Governance for a good example of how Safety Governance should be run.

Finally as damming a statement as you will find in any report, here is an extract from that Royal Commission:

“The (River Pike) company did not have a clear strategy from the board that set out its vision, objectives and targets for health and safety management. It did not treat health and safety as a key corporate risk and prioritise the development of an integrated health and safety management system”

Don’t let that legacy be your legacy…

Pike River Mining Tragedy

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s